Lieberman v. Wyoming.com LLC (I)
Issue is whether withdrawing member of an LLC is entitled to a return of his initial capital contribution only, or is also entitled to the fair market value of his interest in the LLC.
LLC Interest More Than Capital Contribution
The issue in this action for declaratory judgment and dissolution of a limited liability company is whether a withdrawing member of an LLC is entitled to a return of his initial capital contribution only or is also entitled to the fair market value of his interest in the LLC.
Advanced Communication Design, Inc. v. Follett (II)
At issue is whether, in a court-ordered buy-out of a minority shareholder pursuant to Minn. Stat. § 302A.751 (1998), a marketability discount should be applied to the value of the shares.
Berry & Gould, P.A. v. F. Norman Berry
The Maryland Court of Appeals reversed the lower court's award of the value of a OB/GYN practice's goodwill in this unjust enrichment case. The court found that the practice was not under an obligation to purchase the goodwill of a departing shareholder ...
Unjust Enrichment Award Amounting to Goodwill Value Reversed
The Maryland Court of Appeals reversed the lower court's award of the value of a OB-GYN practice's goodwill in this unjust enrichment case.
William C. Musto v. Vincent G. Vidas, et al.
The New Jersey Superior Court affirmed the trial court's decision that the valuation date was the date of commencement in this shareholder appraisal action. It declined to consider post-valuation date profits of the company because the business was valued ...
Post-Valuation Date Increase in Value Considered
The New Jersey Superior Court affirmed the trial court's decision that the valuation date was the date of commencement in this shareholder appraisal action.
Former Shareholder’s Salary Considered When Valuing His Interest Under the Oppressed Shareholder Statute
The Oregon Court of Appeals considered the fair value of a 25% interest in a closely held business in this oppressed shareholder action.
Cooke v. Fresh Express Foods
At issue is the valuation of plaintiff's interest in the defendant, Fresh Express Foods Corporation.
Powell v. Anderson (I)
At issue is the valuation of appellant's interest in the defendant's paper box manufacturing company.
DiLuglio v. Providence Auto Body
At issue is whether the trial justice erred when he failed to discount the value of DiLuglio's shares in PAB because of their relative lack of marketability and lack of controlling status.
Skeen v. Jo-Ann Stores
At issue is whether the minority stockholders had enough financial information to decide whether to accept the merger consideration or seek appraisal.
Additional Information Not Required for Appraisal Rights Decision
The issue in this inadequate disclosure action is whether corporate disclosures to the minority shareholders were adequate under the circumstances.
Medical Practice Valuation Turns on Accounts Receivable
Two rheumatologists, Hensarling and Songcharoen, were equal shareholders of the Jackson Arthritis Clinic and Osteoporosis Center PA.
Hensarling v. Songcharoen
At issue is the value for Songcharoen's stock in the plaintiff and defendant's medical corporation.
In the Matter of the Dissolution of Jackson Arthritis Clinic and Osteoporosis Center
The Supreme Court of Mississippi reversed a trial court's decision which valued a doctor's 50-percent interest in a medical practice for buyout in this dissolution matter. The lower court accepted a valuation using both the asset and capitalized excess e ...
Value of Medical Practice Includes Goodwill and Accounts Receivable
The Supreme Court of Mississippi reversed a trial court's decision that valued a doctor's 50% interest in a medical practice for buyout in this dissolution matter.
Matter of Hahn v. Hahn's Old Fashioned Cake Co., Inc.
The New York Supreme Court, Suffolk County considered the value of a business for the purposes of a shareholder buyout. It considered the expert's testimony using Rev. Rul. 59-60. The court noted that the application of a minority discount was improper u ...
Marketability Discount Permitted in Shareholder Buyout
The New York Supreme Court, Suffolk County, considered the value of a business for the purposes of a shareholder buyout.
Richard Hall v. Donald King, etc., et al.
The New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department affirmed the lower court's decision to value an ongoing antiques reproduction business using the net asset value method. It additionally affirmed the lower court's decision to apply a lack ...
Lack of Marketability Discount Applied to All Corporate Assets
The New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, 1st Department, affirmed the lower court's decision to value an ongoing antiques reproduction business using the net asset value method.
Marketability Discount OK in Oppression Suit
In this case, decided the same day as Lawson Mardon Wheaton Inc. v. Smith, the New Jersey Supreme Court held that a marketability discount should be applied when determining the fair value of stock for purposes of a court-ordered buyout in a shareholder oppression suit.
Balsamides v. Protameen Chemicals
At issue is whether in this judicially ordered buy-out the trial court should have applied a "marketability discount" to determine the "fair value" of Perle's shares, a fifty percent shareholder of Protameen Chemicals.
Marketability Discount Appropriate in New Jersey Minority Oppression Case
The primary issue in this case, decided the same day as Lawson Mardon Wheaton Inc. v. Smith, was whether a marketability discount should be applied is determining the fair value to be paid in a court-ordered buyout in a shareholder oppression suit.
James Bopp, Jr., et al. v. Arnold H. Brames, et al.
The Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed the lower court's calculation of the amount due to a dissolved law partnership by a former partner from the proceeds of a contingency fee case. The lower court calculated the amount due by determining the build-up va ...