Future of IFRS may depend on Big Four accounting firms, says IASB chair

BVWireIssue #124-5
January 30, 2013

“In many ways, Europe’s decision to adopt IFRS in 2005 was a leap into the unknown,” according to Hans Hoogervorst, chair of the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), in recent remarks at the Cass Business School in London. “No one had tried to apply the same, word-for-word set of accounting standards across such a diverse range of economies and cultures. The rest of the world looked on with interest.”

The IASB chair was responding to a just-released report by the Centre for Financial Analysis and Reporting Research at Cass. The report, Accounting for Asset Impairment: A Test for IFRS Compliance Across Europe, shows inconsistencies in IFRS application and compliance by European-listed companies, particularly in impairment reporting practices. He was “not surprised” by the report, which also found that higher quality reporting is more likely in countries with a strong regulatory environment. A recent SEC staff report on IFRS compliance came to similar conclusions, he said. “This goes to show that in an economy as sophisticated as the United States, using a deeply entrenched national GAAP, you still see challenges with consistent application of the standards.”

As for those who cite the inconsistency of IFRS as a reason for nonadoption, Hoogervorst said: “This argument is, of course, nonsense. The truth is that even an unevenly applied global standard provides much more global comparability than an equally unevenly applied multitude of diverging national standards.” Moreover, “without a global standard, there is absolutely no chance you will ever arrive at global comparability. IFRS vastly improves the opportunities to improve application around the world.”

In the immediate future, the IASB will continue to focus on five areas, including improving IFRS implementation, education, enforcement, and international cooperation. “Addressing the challenge of consistency requires coordinated action by standard-setters, auditors, regulators and others,” Hoogervorst said. With their global reach and resources, “the large accounting firms have a particular important role to play.”

Please let us know if you have any comments about this article or enhancements you would like to see.