Beware of relying on industry trend figures when valuing a community bank

BVWireIssue #101-2
February 9, 2011

Dwight Larsen and Matthew Becker (BankValue Advisory Services) told the audience at last week’s 21st  Annual Minnesota BV Conference that bank earnings are on the mend.

  • The banking industry reported an aggregate net income of $53.6B thru 9/30/10 ($1.3B in 2009,, $4.5B in 2008; $100B in 2007)
  • Industry ROA in 2010 3Q equaled 0.44%, up from 0.06% one year prior
  • 18.9% of institutions lost money in 2010 3Q, down from 27% last year
  • 63% of institutions reported year-over-year improvement in net income

However, “most of the improvement in aggregate earnings was concentrated among the largest banks,” Larsen says. “Community banks (less than $1 billion in assets) account for 91% of the total banks outstanding, but only 11% of industry assets and 10% of industry income.” As a result, take caution when looking at industry trend figures.

If you’ve likely to be doing any bank valuations soon, join expert appraiser Andrew Gibbs (Mercer Capital) and attorney Chip MacDonald (Jones Day) next week (February 17) for BVR’s webinar “Valuing Banks,” the latest installment of BVR’s Industry Spotlight Series. Through their 100-minute presentation Gibbs and MacDonald will address both classic considerations and emerging issues.  For more information or to register, click here.

Please let us know if you have any comments about this article or enhancements you would like to see.